There seems to be much discussion on social media about the implications of the current economic conditions on pension funds, and how this may impact financial settlement in divorce cases.
There are so many unknowns at the moment. For example, we do not think anyone has a clear idea as to what the long-term economic impact of government market interventions worldwide will have. We certainly live in interesting and worrying times.
However, we hope the following may help lawyers decide how to proceed with cases involving pensions, as they near settlement.
The combination of all of these factors may require DB schemes to review actuarial basis, with CEVs changing in future. Actuaries are unlikely to change actuarial basis immediately, and so the impact on CEVs will probably not be immediate.
It then gets more complicated if there are combinations of DB / DC funds and public / private sector schemes in a case. See matrix below:
|DC||Private Sector DB|
|Public Sector DB||Public sector DB will have stayed constant, DC fund reduced, therefore may need to revisit settlement whether pension sharing or offsetting||As long as private sector DB scheme is not paying reduced transfer values (on grounds of finding deficit) then probably no need to worry too much whether pension sharing or offsetting. Longer term we would expect private sector DB CEV to increase in value (absent funding problems) but public sector may be constant for longer, leading to some imbalance|
|DC||DC only covered above||Subject to comments above regarding (i) reduced transfer values and (ii) some increase in CEV, the DB CEV may well have stayed relatively constant against a falling DC CEV. Therefore, may need to revisit settlement whether pension sharing or offsetting|
We continue to produce reports. All of our report writers are settled into the routine of home working and producing the reports. We also know from past experience, that notwithstanding market volatility, in so many cases our reports are robust in that even with the benefit of 20/20 hindsight, the calculations withstand the market fluctuations. However, we are inserting the following extra caveat in reports for the time being:
At the time of compiling the report, we are seeing particularly volatile investment markets due to Covid19. We expect pension values to fluctuate more than usual over the next few weeks, and thus whilst the calculations provided in this report will give a very good guide as to the quantum of required orders, it may be the parties decide that some fine tuning, with the benefit of up to date values, would be sensible in this case, as they approach the time for courts to seal any orders.
For example, a report we are currently writing:
(One of the joys of what we do is that no two cases are the same – the possibilities of combinations of pensions are endless. It really is not practical for us to set out similar examples for all possible combinations of pensions.).
i) Staffing problems at life offices / scheme administrators may cause issues with obtaining information required for Form E.
ii) General public concern over markets may cause increased workload for schemes and life offices, at a time when they have reduced staffing levels.
iii) Delays in getting advice regarding the implementation of pension sharing orders.
iv) As a PODE it is necessary for me to surmise what may happen to the value of pensions prior to settlement and indeed post settlement. As a company we will be reviewing our in-house assumptions regularly to ensure our reports adapt to the changing environment. Please do remember that we act as Expert Witness and not as a financial adviser. This company is not authorised to give FCA regulated advice.
The role of a suitably qualified financial adviser becomes even more important in the current market volatility. We believe it is essential that the recipient of a pension sharing order, or offset capital should take regulated financial advice from a suitably qualified financial adviser at the earliest opportunity. The recipient should not wait until he / she receives a pension credit to seek such advice. Where there are lifetime allowance (LTA) issues, we often work in conjunction with the financial adviser for the benefit of both parties.
If the parties do not have their own advisers Brewin Dolphin, our parent company is very experienced in assisting solicitors and their clients in this area. Should you wish to explore how they can help please call them directly on 0203 201 3023 
 In order to preserve our independence when acting as a Single Joint Expert, Mathieson Consulting Ltd requires that contact is made directly to Brewin Dolphin.
We wish you all, your families, and your colleagues all the very best during this troublesome period.
George Mathieson (CEO Mathieson Consulting Ltd)
Dr Catherine Anderson FIA, Senior Actuary Mathieson Consulting Ltd
Jonathan Galbraith FIA, Senior Actuary Mathieson Consulting Ltd
Chris Goodwin FIA, Senior Actuary Mathieson Consulting Ltd
Kate Routledge FIA, Senior Actuary Mathieson Consulting Ltd